Overthinking, Rumination, Anxiety and Your Decisions

People either make decisions very quickly or ruminate forever overthinking everything. Fear drives both, disguised as spirituality.

Making quick decisions is its own kind of indecisiveness: If I just jump and do it, I don’t have to spend time wondering about the decision. Ruminating is paralyzing yourself from making decisions while thinking that you are being wise. One looks decisive, the other looks cautious, but both are driven by fear.

Fear often disguises itself as wisdom. Fear presents itself as responsible, cautious, and practical. The desire for certainty—or omniscience—masquerades itself as wisdom, but it is really a longing for control. We want certainty because certainty feels safe. It removes the risk of making the wrong decision. We want to know the outcome before we take the step. We want the kind of control that removes the risk of making the wrong decision, for the same reason people want to read horoscopes. Fear asks, “What if everything goes wrong?”

But certainty actually removes our dependence on God. Wisdom deepens it. (This is a paradox.)

Fear and wisdom can sound remarkably similar. The difference is that fear is controlled by anxiety, while wisdom is anchored in the character of God.

Remember that Biblical wisdom is rooted in trust. Wisdom is not driven by self-protection. Wisdom asks, “Do I trust God?” “What if God is conspiring for my good?”

Wisdom is about trusting God enough to take the next faithful step. Fear narrows our perspective until all we can see are worst-case scenarios. Wisdom expands our perspective by remembering God’s larger story. Wisdom says,

“I don’t know everything.”

“I’ve sought good counsel.”

“I’ve prayed.”

“I’ve acted with integrity.”

“Now I’ll take the next step.” 

That isn’t recklessness. That’s trust. How about desiring wisdom instead of certainty?

Perfectionism gets in the way because perfectionism is often rooted in shame. It can be an attempt to escape shame rather than pursue excellence. Perfectionism avoids risk. It drives you to strive and protect yourself. And there is very little trust when you are striving for perfection.

Perfectionism rooted in shame doesn’t create belonging. Perfectionism drives you into hiding and out of relationship. But growth flows from belonging. Growth is relational. You need the wisdom of people to help you grow. You will heal and grow in relationship.

God isn’t asking you to become perfect before you can move forward. He is inviting you to grow. That is the relationship God wants with you. He welcomes your imperfect progress.

This desire for certainty doesn’t just affect how we make decisions. It can become a way of living. When we believe we must anticipate every problem, prevent every mistake, and prepare for every possible outcome, anxiety starts doing the work we think wisdom requires. We begin to mistake our anxiety for responsibility.

Anxiety leads also. Anxiety tries to control your future. Anxiety convinces you that it’s being responsible. Anxiety whispers that if you ever relax, stop rehearsing, stop controlling, or stop preparing, you are being irresponsible.

Anxiety leads you to stay in this false fear because it feels responsible but your body can’t hold up. High-functioning anxiety rewards you with productivity and success so anxiety feels necessary. But your body is breaking down.

Anxiety doesn’t necessarily help you discern reality accurately. It can cause you to overestimate the problem while underestimating your ability to handle it.

Instead of growing wiser, you become trapped in avoidance, perfectionism, and control. Your body is staying in a fight-or-flight state because your brain keeps treating imagined future threats as if they are happening right now.

Anxiety isn’t evil. Anxiety is trying to help. It simply isn’t qualified to lead your brain. Anxiety makes a wonderful alarm system but a terrible leader. The alarm is meant to get your attention so you can pause for wisdom. God never intended anxiety to become the voice that leads your brain. Instead God invites you to bring your fears into his presence, where trust gradually replaces control.

Anxiety is not a sin or evidence of weak faith. It is often a signal that something deserves our attention. Anxiety and faith do coexist together.  Your anxiety can lead you to God who can speak to you.

So what do you do when you’re stuck? If you’re praying, analyzing, second-guessing, overthinking, and afraid to move, start here.

First, stop trying to become omniscient. You aren’t going to know everything. And that’s okay.

Second, ask God for wisdom rather than demanding certainty. Pay attention to when fear is leading you. Remember, wisdom is trusting God enough to take the next faithful step.

Third, gather what you already have. Pay attention to what you’re learning about following Jesus. Consider your circumstances. Pay attention to your desires. Listen in prayer. Use common sense. Talk with your Life Team.

Notice I didn’t say read the Bible. Bible reading is slow formation for you to understand God’s larger story perspective which will help you live wiser in every day of your life. What you are reading and praying now is usually getting you ready for decisions you have not yet faced. This makes the Bible less tarot cards, less horoscopes, less AI, and more foundational for your decision making.

Fourth, give yourself space and a deadline for discernment.

You need enough time to listen. But you don’t need unlimited time to think. There comes a point when more thinking isn’t producing more wisdom. It’s producing more anxiety.

Fifth, trust the God who is not fragile.

You are not one decision away from destroying God’s plan for your life. The path is wider and more forgiving than you imagine.

You make small, deliberate tweaks to your thinking because you choose to give God more credibility than everyone else.

You may make an imperfect decision. And if you do, you have not surprised God.

And lastly, celebrate. Celebrate with your Life Team. Feel the joy.

Joy leads in the discernment process. Joy leads our brain. Joy is the fuel our right brain needs to run our left brain functions of problem solving, cause-and-effect, and truth defending. So of course, joy is a part of the process. Be sure to feel the joy.

God’s goal for me and you is not the completion of the checklist. God’s goal is for me and you to be released into the sense of purpose we haven’t been able to shake all of our lives. I hope this deep down sense of purpose is reawakened in you to make these brave decisions.

God is redeemer. God redeems our imperfect decisions, the lessons we learn along the way, and the paths that don’t unfold as we expected. Redemption doesn’t mean every decision was right or every consequence disappears. It means our mistakes and uncertainty don’t have the power to place us beyond God’s work.

Read also:  What is Revealed in the Holy Tension of That Brave Decision

———————————–

New Bible Study:  Trust Issues with God With Video

Life is unfair. When the unfair thing happens, we look for a reason, a solution, a purpose, justice. These are all things we expect from God. When God doesn’t deliver when we expect or need him to, there is a gap in our understanding of who God is. This Bible study is to help you fill in that gap with trust over suspicion by exploring the truths of the Bible, both individually and in a group setting.

Order here: http://TrustIssuesWithGod.com